One of the creators of the Unified Modeling Language, Ivar Jacobson, claims the technology has become too big and needs to be simplified.

In order to watch video content you need to enable javascript and install Flash player version 8 or above.

Jacobson, who helped develop UML, a modelling language used to visualise and blueprint applications, said in an interview with Builder AU that the technology has become less usable as features have been added.

"[UML] needs to be fixed. It needs to be simplified. There's nothing wrong with it, it's just too big. If it's too big people cannot adopt it," Jacobson said.

UML was originally created by Grady Booch, James Rumbaugh and Ivar Jacobson who were collectively known as the "Three Amigos" in the mid-90s. After this time the technology expanded rapidly and started to include support for many industry standards, practices, and players.

Jacobson believes the answer is to create what he is calling Essential UML.

"What we need to do is create Essential UML, which is basically the 20 per cent you need, and the rest you shouldn't even have to touch unless you really want to get into special domains.

"Domain specific languages isn't a new idea ... the problem with this is the same today [as the past] in that if you have no underlying semantics, no core, it's very hard to translate from one language to another. There's a lot of research going on in this area but I have not yet seen something that has yet solved this problem."

"Still, I think languages such as UML has a lot of value but simplification is what's needed," Jacobson said.

Gameplan This was published in Gameplan, check every Wednesday for more stories

Related links

Comments

1

Marcob - 11/09/08

"UML was originally created by Grady Booch, James Rumbaugh and Grady Booch".

1) one Booch in excess
2) one Jacobson missing

:-)

» Report offensive content

2

brendon.chase - 12/09/08

Sorry about that, we're fixing it up now.

» Report offensive content

3

tracy.nelson - 12/09/08

Yeah, I sometimes wonder what I'm missing when I look at UML templates and see all these symbols I don't use (and some I don't even recognize). I find UML indispensible for communicating designs, but I really only use class and sequence diagrams (w/o interaction frames), and occasionally activity diagrams.

One problem that never seems to go away, no matter what notation you use: if you want to show any kind of detail regarding some complex bit of processing, you need an E-size plotter...

» Report offensive content

Leave a comment

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

* indicates mandatory fields.

3

tracy.nelson - 09/12/08

Yeah, I sometimes wonder what I'm missing when I look at UML templates and see all these symbols I don't use ... more

2

brendon.chase - 09/12/08

Sorry about that, we're fixing it up now. ... more

1

Marcob - 09/11/08

"UML was originally created by Grady Booch, James Rumbaugh and Grady Booch". 1) one Booch in excess 2) one Jacobson missing :-) ... more

Log in


Sign up | Forgot your password?

  • Staff Aussies to pay more for Win 7

    If you are looking to make some money in these troubled times, perhaps importing copies of Windows 7 could be for you. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

  • Staff Firefox: Greens want it, 3.5rc2 not up to par

    This week's roundup looks at the situation surrounding a campaign to change Outlook HTML renderer, a Greens MP wants to install Firefox but is restricted and all the photos from the iPhone 3GS launch. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

  • Chris Duckett Microsoft misses the Outlook point

    Ask designers which mail program is the bane of their existence, and you'll find that Outlook tops the list. The reason why the most popular email reader is also the most painful is simple: it uses Word to render HTML emails. Read more »

    -- posted by Chris Duckett

What's on?