Summary
  Testing the Tools


 Introduction
 MS Visual Studio.NET
 Sun Java Studio Creator
 BEA Web Logic Workshop
 Borland C# Builder


If you had to pick one tool from this group that catered for all of the tenets of RAD, you would be hard pressed. Each of the tools we looked at have their own unique strengths and areas where they are better suited to a particular situation. For example, if you are considering a RAD project where you need to quickly create prototypes using a team of developers who have experience with different CLR languages, Visual Studio may provide the best tool for that environment.

On the other hand, if you need to build an application that integrates both .NET and J2EE components and are willing to standarise on a single language, C# Builder may be the best tool for the job. And the plethora of third-party components and add-ins means that you can buy commonly used components rather than build them yourself.

From the Java side of things, it is two-horse race between the tools from BEA and IBM. The distinct advantage that IBM has comes from the Rational tools that IBM has integrated into its productâ€"in a large team environment this can speed development and time between prototype iterations.

So in the end, it depends on the developer resources you have on hand and their skill sets, your preferred platform and required features. While none of the IDEs we have looked at present a complete RAD solution, they do provide enough support for RAD to make them all contenders for your next RAD project.

Related links

Comments

1

Mathias Burbach - 02/10/04

Hello David,

what about Enterprise Core Objects (ECO) in C#Builder. Wouldn't that be worth a paragraph? And with the new version of ECO II coming up in Diamondback (next version of Delphi & C#Builder in one IDE) you can even do reverse engineering your ECO model from an existing database.

Salut,
Mathias

» Report offensive content

2

Doug K - 06/04/05

My heartfelt thanks for this objective and informative article! What are your feelings about Sun's Java Studio Enterprise V.7?

» Report offensive content

Leave a comment

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

* indicates mandatory fields.

2

Doug K - 04/06/05

My heartfelt thanks for this objective and informative article! What are your feelings about Sun's Java Studio Enterprise V.7? ... more

1

Mathias Burbach - 10/02/04

Hello David, what about Enterprise Core Objects (ECO) in C#Builder. Wouldn't that be worth a paragraph? And with the new version of ... more

Log in


Sign up | Forgot your password?

  • Staff Share a keyboard and mouse with Synergy

    Even in the era of virtualization, many IT pros (including myself) have a small army of computers sitting on, under, and around their desks. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

  • Staff Android devs less than gruntled

    Yet more discouraging news on the Android front. Having hacked off its developer community by releasing updated SDKs to just a small group of chosen devs, Google has now given the brush-off to a petition that called for more to be given to the wider community. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

  • Staff VMware shows how not to do it

    As a developer there will be a time when you ship a bug -- be it a stub that you left in, or a flaming, crashtastic segfault. The next time this happens and your bosses come baying for blood, point them in the direction of VMware, who this week gave the developer world a great example of how to ship a showstopper bug. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

What's on?

  • Club Builder: Captain Obvious vs the Crackpots

    In the case of the bleeding obvious, IBM says open source needs good designers; a claim is made that China can activate your phone to snoop on you; and we take a look at the Defcon conference.