Mac OS X 10.5.2: HTML, XML, JavaScript (iBench 5.0)

According to Apple boss Steve Jobs, the company's Safari browser is the fastest on the market. However, Apple has something of a history with benchmarks: when the PowerMac G5 was introduced in 2003, for example, the company was accused of tweaking its test system and hobbling rival Intel-based machines. Since then, of course, Apple has come round to the attractions of Intel processors.

Jobs' statement that the fastest Safari browser is based on tests the company has carried out using iBench 5.0. However, these benchmark results should be treated with caution: manual measurements with a stopwatch show that Safari is not quite as fast as iBench suggests. This is because, as mentioned earlier, iBench uses the JavaScript 'onload' event to determine page loading time, which Safari triggers before the page has in fact finished loading. Even so, despite these caveats, there's no doubt that Safari is indeed a fast browser.

Safari 3.1.0 is quickest in the HTML tests with a time of under 10 seconds, placing it well ahead of Opera 9.27's 48 seconds. However, the STAND Safari plug-in extends the load time to over 18 seconds — perhaps because it prevents the premature page-loading statement normally reported by iBench. The beta version of Opera 9.5 manages to reduce the load time from over 48 seconds in version 9.27 to less than 20 seconds. In the XML/CSS test, Safari again takes first place — and here, the STAND plug-in has no significant impact on performance. Opera brings up the rear in this test, and this time the 9.5 beta brings no improvement.

Safari is the winner in the JavaScript tests too. These tests also demonstrate the benefits that browser development can deliver. Among the beta versions, Firefox 3 Beta 5 is particularly impressive compared to its predecessor, reducing Firefox 2.0.13's 3.91 seconds to just 1.07 seconds in the HTML/JavaScript DOM test. Opera and Safari also deliver significant performance improvements in their respective betas.

Timings in seconds: shorter bars are better.

Timings in seconds: shorter bars are better.

Mac OS X 10.5.2: SunSpider JavaScript

Of the current Mac OS X browsers, Safari 3.1 is clearly the fastest in the SunSpider JavaScript benchmark. However, Firefox 3 Beta 5 beats Apple's browser by a noticeable margin. Elsewhere, the Opera 9.5 beta improves on its predecessor, although it cannot match the performance of Safari and Firefox 3 Beta 5.

The individual tests show exactly how Firefox 3 Beta 5 has overhauled Safari, and where Opera needs to improve in order to catch Firefox and Safari. For example, Firefox 3 Beta 5 took 187 milliseconds for the bit operations test, compared to the current version's 2,241ms. Opera 9.5 Beta also improves on the current version, but not to the same extent.

Comments

1

H - 23/07/08

He he, its a funny post. Clearly the market is usually IE vs Firefox but now that you include opera. OUAHHHHAAHAHA. You are disgusting to compare any browser today aginst Firefox.

code is that ][You Suck][

» Report offensive content

2

G - 14/08/08

You forgot something... Linux.

Firefox is quicker on linux than on mac/vista.

» Report offensive content

3

Randy - 02/10/08

I wonder how Google's Chrome Browser would perform..

» Report offensive content

Leave a comment

You must read and type the 6 chars within 0..9 and A..F

* indicates mandatory fields.

3

Randy - 10/02/08

I wonder how Google's Chrome Browser would perform.. ... more

2

G - 14/08/08

You forgot something... Linux. Firefox is quicker on linux than on mac/vista. ... more

1

H - 23/07/08

He he, its a funny post. Clearly the market is usually IE vs Firefox but now that you include opera. OUAHHHHAAHAHA. ... more

Log in


Sign up | Forgot your password?

  • Staff A first look at Windows 7 beta

    In this week's Roundup we show you a preview of Windows 7 beta, cover news from the annual Macworld and more. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

  • Staff Opera's new SDK: Better browsing on the Wii?

    Opera has thrown a little more love at device developers by announcing an updated version of its software development kit on Wednesday at CES. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

  • Staff 2008: Time to call stumps

    It's another year down but some things never change. That was shown this week as Internet Explorer remained under fire from yet another zero-day exploit. In other news, we set a hard drive on fire and Apple cans its involvement with MacWorld. Read more »

    -- posted by Staff

What's on?